пятница, 2 марта 2012 г.

Generation's End: A Personal Memoir of American Power After 9/11

Malcomson, Scott L. Generation's End: A Personal Memoir of American Power After 9/11. Washington, D.C.: Potomac Books, 2010. 264 pp. $27.50.

While Scott Malcomson offers an engaging memoir of his experience at the New York Times and in New York after terrorists brought down the World Trade Center, Generation's End Offers little insight for media history scholars into how the Times covered the horrific events.

Malcomson was foreign affairs editor for the Times' op-ed pages when Mohammed Atta and his co-conspirators guided commercial airliners into the twin towers and the Pentagon on September 11, 2001. His memoir is a personal journey to understand how the horrific event changed New York and the United States.

The first four chapters will be of most interest to journalism historians. His job at the New York Times provides a recurring theme as Malcomson relates his day-today experiences after the attack. His job at the newspaper was to work with op-ed contributors, solicit contributions from key policy-makers and commentators, and edit the final articles.

In the days following the attack, Malcomson scrambled to find appropriate commentary to help explain the event and what it meant for the future. He and his colleague, Mary Suh, sought contributors and tried to think of angles that would be relevant in the days ahead. He says they called former secreraries of state, terrorism experts, engineers who could explain why the towers fell, and airline security specialists as well as seeking out fiction writers, historians and others who could expound on the human condition. This section, though brief, provides insight into the decision-making process of editors as they prepared the op-ed section in the days following the attack.

Malcomson, who had been hired by the Times to bring more foreign affairs to the op-ed page, acknowledges that before 9/11, the op-ed page paid little attention to events beyond the borders of the United States. That changed after 9/11, he says. Interestingly, in the days following the attack, Times readers flooded the editorial department with commentary and - a bit surprising unless one considers the role that art plays in life - poetry, pictures, and photographs. He reports that the unsolicited articles that the editors received primarily dealt with why the attack occurred and what should be done in response.

Unfortunately, Malcomson provides few insights into the workings of the Times during its coverage of 9/11 and the aftermath. While he discusses the Times' poor response to the Bush administration's march towaid war with Iraq, there is no analysis of the Judith Millei contioveisy. That is a notable omission because some critics have argued that her news stories helped the Bush administration sell its war against Iraq by uncritically reporting false information about weapons of mass destruction. Given that Malcomson discusses the Times' indecisive coverage and commentary about the administration's buildup to war with Iraq, failure to discuss the controversy over the paper's news coverage is problematic. Granted, he does not claim to have written a definitive New York Times history of this period, but it is misleading to discuss the Times' coverage without broaching the contioveisy.

Tellingly, Malcomson writes that the newspaper's editors treaded lightly around the story, reluctant to challenge the administration in either the news columns or on the editorial page. He notes that the White House and the Iraqis refused to give Times reporters access to information, but that observation ignores the reporting that Miller was doing. Much of the indecision on the part of the Times, according to him, was from the paper's loss of political and economic status as politics shifted away from liberalism towards Rush Limbaugh conservatism and the Internet eroded the printed product's financial security.

The book's two final chapters relate Malcomson's move from the New York Times to the United Nations, where he woiked as diiectoi of communication for the High Commissione! for Human Rights. From this position, he woiked to place op-ed atticles instead of editing the commentaiy of others. The book ends as his position with the United Nations was becoming untenable aftei his boss, Sergio Vieria de Mello, became the special United Nations envoy for Iraq only to be murdered in Baghdad by a teiioiist's bomb. Ultimately he returned to the papei as foreign editor of the New York Times Magazine.

As a memoir, Generations End gives a heart-felt and intelligent peisonal account of what the attack on the World Trade Center meant to individuals, especially New Yoikers. And to his credit, Malcomson takes the book beyond a memoir to offer a smart critique of American power before and after the attack. Also woven throughout are his brief but astute observations about the media, particularly the New York Times' editorial pages. Nevertheless, journalism scholars will wish he had provided more insight into the workings of the Times during a critical time in our history.

[Author Affiliation]

James Aucoin

University of South Alabama

Комментариев нет:

Отправить комментарий